"Slavery has always existed" is not a compelling argument against reparations or addressing racial injustice in the United States.
"Slavery has always existed" is not a compelling argument against reparations or addressing racial injustice in the United States. Yes, it’s true that forms of slavery have existed across many societies throughout history. But what matters in this context is not the fact that slavery existed elsewhere — it's the specific legacy of chattel slavery as practised in the United States, and the ongoing impact it has on African Americans today. The key point is that American slavery was not some vague historical inconvenience. It was a foundational institution that built the early economy of the United States — through free labour that generated massive wealth for white landowners and the country at large, while black Americans were systematically excluded from the benefits. And after slavery ended, the injustice didn’t stop. It evolved into Jim Crow laws, redlining, mass incarceration, voter suppression, underfunded schools in black neighbourhoods, and discriminatory pol...